+ THORACIC DROP: < Deposit > news appropriate to this site.

+ AUTOGEDDON: Subscribe to Ballardian & receive automatic email updates

Cosmic Sentinels and Spiral Jetties: J.G. Ballard, Robert Smithson & Tacita Dean

Author: • Mar 3rd, 2013 •

Category: architecture, deep time, features, film, Lead Story, Robert Smithson, Tacita Dean, temporality, urban decay, urban ruins, visual art

By Andrew Frost


Robert Smithson’s Spiral Jetty (1970). Photo: George Steinmetz, 2002.

Tacita Dean’s new film, JG, is currently on view at the Arcadia University Art Gallery, Glenside, Philadelphia. The film is inspired by Dean’s correspondence with J.G. Ballard, and explores connections between Ballard’s short story ‘The Voices of Time’ and Robert Smithson’s iconic earthwork and film Spiral Jetty. To celebrate this important new work, Andrew Frost explores the enduring and mysterious relationship between Ballard, Smithson and Dean.

JG (2013), by Tacita Dean. Commissioned by and made for the Arcadia University Art Gallery and funded by The Pew Center for Arts & Heritage. On view from February 7 through April 21, 2013.

Andrew Frost is an art critic, writer, broadcaster and lecturer, based in New South Wales, Australia.

FOLLOWING a long-held and frankly absurd desire to collect every interesting SF film available on DVD, I recently relented and ordered a copy of Phase IV, the only feature film to be directed by celebrated title designer Saul Bass. I say ‘relented’ because the DVD of this obscure 1974 film had sat in my Amazon wish list for a couple of years and I wasn’t entirely sure it would be worth it. But it turned out to be a genuine curiosity, a strange mixture of corny 50s style SF and early 70s dystopia. The story concerns the sudden appearance of sentience among some unspecified species of ant and the film has distinctly Ballardian touches. Lesko and Hubbs, two scientists in a camp out in middle of the Arizona desert, study the formation of an ant hive mind, the most explicit expression of this collective intelligence being a series of rectangular monoliths built from sand by the ants. The purpose of the structures is unknown and their destruction by the scientists is the dramatic moment when the ants begin their final assault against the humans.

Phase IV

Phase IV (1974; dir. Saul Bass).

While J.G. Ballard’s own fiction rarely ventured into such pulp tinged territory, Phase IV has moments that evoke the elegiac feel of the Ballardian desert, with its rocky expanse shot in Africa, although set in the US, already a Ballardian territory. One could just as easily imagine Lesko and Hobbs drinking after work in one of the hotel bars in Vermilion Sands. The most obvious Ballardian connection is of course the sand monoliths, structures eerily reminiscent of the sentinels in Ballard’s short story ‘The Waiting Grounds’ (1959), but also familiar as generic elements in what has been called Land Art.

Land Art typically features interventions into the landscape by artists working at various scales. At one end of the spectrum are artists such as Richard Long and Andy Goldsworthy, whose interventions had low impacts, like wearing down grass into a track, as in Long’s A Line Made By Walking (1967) or Goldsworthy’s structures using materials from various sites such as stones arrayed in circles, built into walls or mounds, sited near where they were collected. At the other end of the spectrum are the massive and imposing structures of Michael Hesier’s City (1972-ongoing) in which the artist has slowly built a series of city-scale ‘sculptures’ that evoke Mayan pyramids. Just as gigantic but perhaps less grandiose, James Turrell’s Roden Crater (1979-ongoing) is a volcano crater that has been slowly transformed into an amphitheatre for viewing the sky, while Walter De Maria’s Lightning Field (1977) features 400 stainless steel posts erected over a one mile by one mile field in the desert in New Mexico, attracting lightning strikes and the changing light of day and seasons.


Lightning Field (Walter De Maria; 1977). Photo via.

The common thread throughout many Land Art works is the use of geometric shapes and repetition, in part derived from the movement’s roots in Minimalist sculpture, but also perhaps a result of the effective simplicity of drawing lines and creating mounds and monoliths in dramatic expanses such as deserts and mountain ranges, an architectural form known to humans since ancient times, and visually powerful in their suggestion of time, entropy and the universe.

Robert Smithson (1938–1973) created Spiral Jetty in 1970 and it has proved to be one of the key works of the Land Art movement. The work was built using black basalt rocks and earth at a lonely point on the shores of Utah’s Great Salt Lake. It is a giant coil some 1,500 feet long and 15 feet wide that stretches out counter-clockwise into the translucent waters near Rozel Point. When Smithson built the sculpture, the water level at the lake was at an historic low and in the years since it has only been occasionally visible. Visits to the remote location are possible and have attracted a special kind of adventurous art tourist.

Smithson, as has been well documented, was a reader of science fiction. He read Ballard and appropriated Earthworks, his preferred term for Land Art, from the novel of the same name by Brian Aldiss. Smithson worked on a number of unrealised, explicitly SF themed projects including a documentary film on flying saucers, and drafted plans to build a monument in Antarctica that has a possibly not-coincidental doppelganger in Adrian Veidt’s Antarctic base in the recent film version of Watchmen. Smithson found within Ballard’s writing a significant point of reference for his own artistic ideas. In his essay ‘The Artist As Site-Seer: Or, A Dintorphic Essay’ (1966-7), Smithson cites The Waiting Grounds and its story of ambiguous and encoded monolithic objects.


Smithson’s drawing of the Spiral Jetty.

Smithson theorised a cosmic scale for the potential of sculpture and architecture, speculating that certain forms like the Great Pyramid contain within them fundamental numerical relationships in their formal ratios, but also that monumental sculptures might also contain within them the seeds of language, as do the sculptures in Ballard’s story. The Great Pyramid, claimed Smithson, was an ‘awesome computer based on orbital chronologies and shifting calendars’ that ‘is an agglomeration of codes, puzzles, clocks, tombic theories, secret passages and lacunary mathematics’. Smithson’s hope was that his own work could somehow achieve this rich mixture of cultural and scientific reference points.

This semi-mystical view of sculptural form is reminiscent of various Ballard stories in which an artist or scientist labours at an obscure task that ultimately reveals a cosmic truth, such as the revelation in The Waiting Grounds that language precedes consciousness. In The Voices of Time (1960), another Ballard story cited by Smithson, and one often connected to the Spiral Jetty, a cosmic countdown signals the approach of an eternity of sleep for humankind. The protagonist, Powers, after encountering a spiral structure meant to represent the square root of -1, surrenders to the flow of cosmic time within a spiral mandala, located on the salt lake of an abandoned air force testing range. Ballard’s use of the spiral as a symbol for cosmic time, from the scale of the sculpture to the magnitude of the galaxy, finds its expression in Smithson’s sculptures.

Excerpts from Smithson’s film of the Spiral Jetty.

Smithson was killed in 1973 in a light plane crash while he was surveying sites in Texas. Despite his untimely death, his work has proven influential for a subsequent generations of artists and his estate’s website notes his art has been the subject of major exhibitions in the Europe and the US since the mid-1970s. The Spiral Jetty itself has taken on an iconic status, perhaps much in the spirit of those rare or lost albums that are rediscovered and appraised once more as masterworks, due to successive generations of artists looking to Smithson’s purity of intent and reasoning a background to their own work. That the Jetty has been literally lost to view for decades as it slumbered beneath the water gave it a ghostly presence in late modernist art. Smithson’s film of the Jetty, with its zooms and swoops over the rocks and lake, and the voice over, a blur of tripped-out incantory prose quoting numerous sources including John Taine’s 1931 story The Time Stream, only made that ghost all the more alluring.

In the mid-1990s, British artist Tacita Dean decided to see if she could find a trace of the Spiral Jetty. Traveling to Utah and using complicated directions to Rozel Point – located some two hours from Salt Lake City and 12 miles into the wilderness of the Golden Spike National Historic Site – Dean and her travelling companion became lost. Recording the trip using a tape recorder and a 35mm stills camera, Dean produced two key works from the trip, a sound recording, Trying To Find The Spiral Jetty (1997), and an installation projection of her 35mm slides, Rozel Point, Great Salt Lake, Utah (1999). The sound work was based on recordings of Dean and friend attempting to find the Jetty, which was later embellished and supplemented, turning the piece into an extended work of fiction. Ultimately the trip led the pair to the outcrop adjacent to Smithson’s work, but there was nothing to see except a vast expanse of calm water.

When the two pieces were exhibited in London, Ballard sent the artist a copy of a catalogue essay he had written on Smithson’s work. Writing a tribute to Ballard in The Guardian in 2009 after his death, Dean recalled the connections between writer and artist:

“Beneath the Great Salt Lake was, for some, the centre of an ancient universe, and [Smithson’s] jetty could have been an elaborate means to bore down to get to it. As if understanding this, Ballard wrote in the catalogue text: ‘What cargo might have berthed at the Spiral Jetty?’ He elaborated later to me in a letter: ‘My guess is that the cargo was a clock, of a very special kind. In their way, all clocks are labyrinths, and can be risky to enter.’ The two men had a lot in common, and Ballard believed [Smithson] to be the most important and most mysterious of post-war US artists. My interest in time, cosmic and human, future and past, as well as the analogue spooling of the now, has Ballard at its core…”


The Green Ray (2001; Tacita Dean).

Dean’s own work as an artist had long touched on Ballardian themes, most notably her film work The Green Ray (2001), in which she had used a 16mm camera in an attempt to capture the allusive optical effect seen when the sun dips below the ocean’s horizon, and Disappearance at Sea (1996), a sequence of multi-media works including sculptures, a photography book and a film installation, responding to the story of Donald Crowhurst, the sailor who, in the 1968 Sunday Times Golden Globe Single-Handed Round-the-World Yacht Race, suffered a nervous breakdown that ultimately resulted in his death. But not before Crowhurst recorded his insights into the cosmic insignificance of man in the face of the uncaring universe. Indeed, Dean had drawn Ballard’s attention to the demise of Crowhurst’s vessel, The Teignmouth Electron, now abandoned on the shore of Cayman Brac, after she had travelled there to record its remains. The three-hulled vessel was a forlorn object that Dean imagined had been lifted from Ballard’s writings:

“Now as I walked along the road which ran parallel to the runway and caught sight of the trimaran in the undergrowth, more than ever did I place it in his fictional world, a world where the sea had retreated and left our boats stranded, or had risen and taken off our harbours to strange and unfit places…”


JG, Tacita Dean, 2013. Color and black & white 35mm film with optical sound, 26½ minutes Courtesy of the artist and Frith Street Gallery, London/Marian Goodman Gallery, New York/Paris.

Now, at the Arcadia University Art Gallery, Tacita Dean’s latest film project, JG, is shown. It’s a major piece inspired by Dean’s correspondence with Ballard, and in particular his observations on Smithon’s Jetty and his encouragement to her that she should ‘treat the Spiral Jetty as a mystery her film would solve.’ Dean has revisited Rozel Point and recorded the landscape and the now visible Jetty. The work elaborates upon a technique she developed for an installation at the Tate Modern’s Turbine Hall in 2011 where the artist, using 35mm film, shoots and reshoots lengths of film using selective masking to create a visual collage of elements in the final image. Dean is interested, like Smithson and Ballard, in the repetition of visual and thematic elements at various levels. She likens the spiral of the analogue film loop to the spiral of the jetty and the spiral nebulae in The Voices of Time.

Writing on the film for the Pew Center for the Arts, Dean noted that the repetition of the spiral occurs throughout the fictions of Ballard’s text and Smithson’s sculpture:

‘It literally sees time,’ Powers says of an experiment on a sunflower in ‘The Voices of Time’. So also does the spiral at the heart of all our biological, chemical and cosmological structures. As does, I realized as I worked at my cutting table, the indexical nature of film itself. ‘A film is a spiral made up of frames,’ Smithson wrote. JG needed to be made now because its medium and its form is the analog of the underlying equation of our universe, and it is breaking up and saying goodbye.


JG (Tacita Dean, 2013).

The masking of the film has another Ballard reference point. As the Arcadia gallery’s website records:

“Among the masks used in JG is one that references the template and sprocket holes of a strip of 35mm Ektachrome slide film… a reference to Ballard’s own 35mm camera, which Dean was given by Claire Walsh, the author’s longtime partner, just prior to the shoot and which is depicted in the film.”

There is another layer at which Ballard and Smithson connect (and perhaps Dean and other artists influenced by these two great figures of ‘fin des siècle Wagnerian modernism’, as Frederic Jameson put it). Dean writes: ‘J.G. Ballard summons up a time when our everyday will be out of context; when our descendants will read votive meaning in our sports stadiums and race courses; when nothing will be understood by the totems of today.’

A repetition of form, a mirroring of components and other aesthetic considerations may be found in their work, and these are interesting aesthetic considerations, yet it was Dean who effectively summarised Ballard’s modus operandi, and Smithson’s approach, namely a recognition of the poetry of the desert and the ruin, the making strange of our own time through an acute recognition of our place within what Smithson called deep time.


JG (Tacita Dean, 2013).

Find all posts by

Older: «

12 Responses »

  1. thanks

  2. a fascinating read

  3. Nice piece, perhaps we could fit P K dick in there as well with his short story “Impossible Planet”

  4. Outstanding piece, thanks so much.

  5. […] Read the complete article. […]

  6. Lovely post. Smithson’s connections to speculative fiction were deep, and must have been profoundly shaped by his reading of Ballard. In his “Entropy and the New Monuments” (1966), he makes the distinctly Ballardian observation that, “instead of causing us to remember the past like the old monuments, the new monuments seem to cause us to forget the future.” And when, in “The Crystal Land” (1966), Smithson, driving back from a trip to rock quarries, describes “glanc[ing] over the dashboard…a complex of chrome fixed into an embankment of steel,” there is little doubt of his debt to Ballard. Much could be said, too, for the formal affinities of Smithson’s “Quasi-Infinities and the Waning of Space” (1966) to Ballard’s “encyclopedic” stories. Smithson’s two best known essays, “A Tour of the Monuments of Passaic”(1967) and “Incidents of Mirror-Travel in the Yucatan” (1968) also both recount explicitly Ballardian voyages through psychic geographies. Your acknowledgments, too, of the relation to the work of Michael Heizer and James Turrell were also apposite, not least for their quixotic aspects. Thanks again for an excellent and provocative post.

  7. Thanks for the interesting post. Just watched the Lily Cole’s Art Matters (on Sky Arts) where she meets with Tacita Dean and as soon as I saw some of her work I thought of JG Ballard’s work.

  8. […] and the Waning of Space’ (1966, sadly a bit difficult to read in this form). There’s also a really solid article by Andrew Frost at ballardian.com. Suffice to say there is much to be read and thought around this […]

  9. Piece in the UK Guardian about Tacita Dean, Ballard and Smithson

  10. Great Posting. The JG installation at Frith st gallery is incredible. Good to hear the reference scope here

  11. […] dystopian novel of the same name), and he passed away before seeing through his plan for a UFO documentary. Marfa, Texas, home to the Judd Foundation, is a spooky, deserted town, perhaps better-known in […]

  12. I am currently the 35mm projectionist for the installation of “JG” at the Hammer Museum in Los Angeles and a fan of Smithson’s ever since a show at LACMA many years back. It is interesting how the 35mm film wound on the reel also resembles a spiral and is composed of silver crystals not unlike those of salt. Also interesting is Ballard’s use of the term “cargo cultist” as “Cargo Cult” was the art theme of Burning Man 2013.

Leave a Reply